IJSER Home >> Journal >> IJSER
International Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research
ISSN Online 2229-5518
ISSN Print: 2229-5518 2    
Website: http://www.ijser.org
scirp IJSER >> Volume 3,Issue 2,February 2012
Impact Analysis : Deciphering the Advantages and Limitations in Improving Processes using Six Sigma, JIT,TQM and SCM- A Thorough Study
Full Text(PDF, )  PP.303-313  
Author(s)
NILESH VIJAY FURSULE, Dr. SATISH V. BANSOD ( Ph.D), SWATI N. FURSULE
KEYWORDS
Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, DMAIC, JIT, SCM, TQM,
ABSTRACT
TQM and SCM have both played and increasing role in strengthening implementing Six Sigma. Six Sigma is both a philosophy and a methodology that improves quality Despite the pervasiveness of Six Sigma program implementations, there is increasing concern about implementation failures. Research on Just-in-Time (JIT), Total Quality Management (TQM), Six Sigma ( SS) and Supply Chain Management (SCM) generally investigate the implementation and impact of these programs in isolation. However, many researchers believe and argue conceptually the value of understanding the joint implementation and effect of manufacturing programs. However , one reason many Six Sigma programs fail is because an implementation model on how to effectively guide the implementation of these programs is lacking. While Six Sigma is increasingly implemented in industry, little academic research has been done on Six Sigma and its influence on quality management theory and application. There is a criticism that Six Sigma simply puts traditional quality management practices in a new package. To investigate this issue and the role of Six Sigma in quality management, this study reviewed both the traditional quality management and Six Sigma literatures. Quality professionals are aware that the six-sigma methodology employs existing, well-known tools developed in quality sciences and are based on the works of Deming, Juran, Ishikawa, Taguchi, and others. Nevertheless six sigma, a Motorola innovation, has been a positive force. This paper addresses benefits and limitations of implementing Six Sigma in combination to TQM through a through study.
References
[1] Ahire, S.L., Dreyfus, P., 2000. The impact of design management and process management on quality: an empirical examination. Journal of Operations Management 18, 549–575.

[2] Ahire, S.L., O’Shaughnessy, K.C., 1998. The role of top management commitment in quality management: an empirical analysis of the auto parts industry. International Journal of Quality Science 31, 5–37.

[3] Andel, T.,2007.Lean & Six Sigma Traps to Avoid. Material Handling Management, March /http://www.mhmonline.com/viewStory.asp? nID=5423S.

[4] Angel, D.C., Pritchard,C.,2008. Behaviortests SixSigma. Industrial Engineer (August),41.

[5] Antony,J.,Banuelas,R.,2002. Key in gredients for the effective implementation of Six Sigma program. Measuring Business Excellence 6(4), 20–27.

[6] Banuelas, R., Tennant, C.,Tuersley, I.,Tang, S., 2006. Selection of Six Sigma projects in the UK. The TQM Magazine 18(5), 514–527.

[7] Barney, M., 2002a. Macro: Six Sigma. The Industrial Organizational Psychologist 39 (4), 104–107.

[8] Barney, M., 2002b. Motorola’s second generation. Six Sigma Forum Magazine 1 (3), 13–16.

[9] Beer, M., 2003. Why total quality management programs do not persist: the role of management quality and implications for leading a TQM transformation. Decision Sciences 34, 623–642.

[10] Belson, K., 2004. Japanese capital and jobs flowing to China. New York Times, February 17, C, p. 1.

[11] Bendell, T.,2006.Are view and comparison of Six Sigma and the lean organizations. The TQM Magazine18(3), 255–262.

[12] Berg, M., 2006. Six Sigma shortcomings. Industrial Engineer(October), 45.

[13] Bessant, J., Caffyn, S., 1997. High-involvement innovation through continuous improvement. International Journal of Technology Management 14 (1), 7–28.

[14] Bhote, K.R., 2003. The Power of Ultimate Six Sigma: Keki Bhote’s Proven System for Moving Beyond Quality Excellence to Total Business Excellence. AMACOM American Management Association, New York, NY.

[15] Bremner, B., Edmondson, G., Dawson, C., Welch, D., Kerwin, K., 2004. Nissan’s boss: Carlos Ghosn saved Japan’s no. 2 carmaker. Now he’s taking on the world. Business Week, October 4, 50–58.

[16] Brewer, P.C., 2004. Six Sigma helps a company create a culture of accountability. Journal of Organizational Excellence 23 (3), 45–59.

[17] Breyfogle,F.,Cipello,J.,Meadows,B.,2001.ManagingSixSigma. Wiley Inter Science, New York, NY.

[18] Chakravorty,S.S.,Atwater,J.B.,1998.Implementingqualityimp rovement programs using the focusing steps of the array of constraints. International Journal of Technology Management 16 (4/5/6/), 544–555.

[19] Chakravorty,S.S., Atwater, J.B., 2006. Bottleneck management : theory and practice. Production & Planning Control17 (5), 441–447.

[20] Chakravorty, S.S., Sessum,J.L., 1995. Developing effective strategies to prioritize setup reduction in multi machine production system.

[21] Cheng, J.L., 2006. DMAIC integration necessary for success. ASQSIX Sigma Forum Magazine5(4),22–28.

[22] Choi, T.Y., Eboch, K., 1998. The TQM paradox: relations among TQM practices, plant performance, and customer satisfaction. Journal of Operations Management 17, 59–75.

[23] Choo, A.S., Linderman, K.W., Schroeder, R.G., 2004. Method and context perspectives on learning and knowledge creation in quality management. Journal of Operations Management 25 (4), 918–931.

[24] Clifford, L., 2001. Why you can safely ignore Six Sigma. Fortune January, 140.

[25] Coronado, R.B.,Antony,J., 2002. Critical success factors for the successful implementation of Six Sigma projects in organisations. The TQM Magazine 14(2),92–99.

[26] Cyert, R.M., March, J.G., 1963. A Behavioral Theory of the Firm. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.

[27] Dasgupta, T., 2003. Using the six-sigma metric to measure and improve the performance of a supply chain. Total Quality Management & Business Excellence 14 (3), 355–367.

[28] Davison,L.,Al-shaghana,K.,2007. The link between Six Sigma and quality culture — an empirical study. Total Quality Management 18(3), 249–265.

[29] Davis T. Effective supplychain management. Sloan Management Review 1993;12:35–46. Economist, 2004. (Still) made in Japan, April 7.

[30] Eisenhardt, K.M., Martin, J.A., 2000. Dynamic capabilities: what are they? Strategic Management Journal 21 (October– November Special Issue), 1105–1121.

[31] Feng, Q.,Manuel,C.M.,2007.Under the knife: an ational survey of Six Sigma programs in US health care organizations. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance 21(6),535–547.

[32] Flynn, B.B., Sakakibara, S., 1995. Relationship between JIT and TQM: practices and performance. Academy of Management Journal 38 (5), 1325–1360.

[33] Forza, C., Flippini, R., 1998.TQMimpact on quality conformance and customer satisfaction: a causal model. International Journal of Production Economics 55, 1–20.

[34] Foster,S.T.,2007.Does Six Sigma improve performance? The Quality Management Journal14(4),7–20.

[35] Garvin, D., 1988. Managing Quality: The Strategic and Competitive Edge. Free Press, New York, NY, p. 22.

[36] Garvin, D.A., 1993b. Manufacturing strategic planning . California Management Review 35 (4), 85–106.

[37] Gijo,E.V.,Rao,T.L.,2005. Six Sigma implementation— hurdles and more hurdles. Total Quality Management 16(6),721–725.

[38] Goffnett, S.P., 2004. Understanding Six Sigma: implications for industry and education. Journal of Industrial Technology 20 (4), 1–10.

[39] Gopal, R.,2008. 10 ways to failure for a new Six Sigma program. /http://www.isixsigma.com/library/content/c071203a.aspS.

[40] Gowen III, C.R., Tallon, W.J., 2005. Effect of technological intensity on the relationships among Six Sigma design, electronic-business, and competitive advantage: a dynamic capabilities model study. Journal of High Technology Management Research 16 (1), 59–87.

[41] Gupta, P.,2008. Reducing the cost of failures. Quality Digest 47 (1), 22.

[42] Hackman, J., Wageman, R., 1995. Total quality management: empirical, conceptual, and practical issues. Administrative Science Quarterly 40 (2), 309–343.

[43] Hales, D.N., Chakravorty,S.S., 2006.Implementation of Deming’s style of Quality management : an action research study. International Journal of Production Economics 103,31–148.

[44] Handfield, R ., Ghosh, S., Fawcett, S., 1998. Quality driven change and its effects on financial performance. Quality Management Journal 5 (3), 13–30.

[45] Harry,M.J., Linsenmann, D.R.,2007. The Six Sigma Field book : How Du Pont Successfully Implemented the Six Sigma Breakthrough Strategy. Double day Business of Random House, Inc.,NewYork, NY.

[46] Helfat, C.E., Finkelstein, S., Mitchell, W., Peteraf, M.A., Singh, H., Teece, D.J., Winter, S.G., 2007. Dynamic Capabilities: Understanding Strategic Change in Organizations. Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA.

[47] Henderson, K.M., Evans, J.R., 2000. Successful implementation of Six Sigma: benchmarking general electric company. Benchmarking: An International Journal 7 (4), 260–281.

[48] Hendricks, C.A., Kelbaugh, R., 1998. Implementing Six Sigma at GE. The Journal of Quality and Participation 21 (4), 48–53.

[49] Hindo, B.,2007.At3M, a struggle between efficiency and creativity. Business Week,June11.

[50] Hindo, B.,Grow,B.,2007. Six Sigma: so yesterday. BusinessWeek, June 11.

[51] Kaynak, H., 2003. The relationship between total quality management practices and their effects on firm performance. Journal of Operations Management 21 (4), 405–435.

[52] Keller,P.,2005. Six Sigma: Demystified. McGraw-Hill, NewYork, NY.

[53] Kiernan, M.J., 1996. Get innovative or get dead. Business Quarterly 61 (1), 51–58.

[54] Kwak, Y.H., Anbari, F.T., 2004. Benefits, obstacles, and future of Six Sigma approach. Technovation 26 (5/6), 708– 715.

[55] Ladani, L.J.,Das,D., Cartwright,J.L., Yenker,R., Razmi,J., 2006.Implementation of Six Sigma system in celestica with practical examples. International Journal of Six Sigma and Competitive Advantage 2(1), 69–88.

[56] Lakhavani,S.T.,2003. Six Sigma implementations: trials, tribulations, and lessons learned. ASQ’s Annual Quality Congress Proceedings 57, 643–647.

[57] Larson PD, Rogers DS. Supply chain management: definition, growth and approaches. Journal of Marketing 1998;6(4):1–5.

[58] Lee , Choi ,2006. Six Sigma: a vital improvement approach when applied to the right problems, in the right environment. Assembly Automation26(1), 10–18.

[59] Lee-Mortimer, A., 2006. Six Sigma: a vital improvement approach when applied to the right problems, in the right environment. AssemblyAutomation26(1),10–18.

[60] Linderman, K., Schroeder, R.G., Choo, A.S., 2006. Six Sigma: the role of goals in improvement teams. Journal of Operations Management 24 (6), 779–790.

[61] Linderman, K., Schroeder, R.G., Zaheer, S., Choo, A.S., 2003. Six Sigma: a goal-theoretic perspective. Journal of Operations Management 21 (2), 193–204.

[62] Linderman, K., Schroeder, R.G., Zaheer, S., Liedtke, C., Choo, A.S., 2004. Integrating quality management practices with knowledge creation processes. Journal of Operations Management 22 (6), 589–607.

[63] Lynch,D.P., Bertolino,S., Cloutier,E., 2003. How to scope DMAIC projects. Quality Progress36(1),37–41.

[64] Mahoney, J.T., 1995. The management of resources and the resource of management. Journal of Business Research 33 (2), 91–101.

[65] Mast, J.D., Bisgaard,S., 2007. The science in Six Sigma. Quality Progress 40 (1),25–29.

[66] Mcadam, R., Evans, A., 2004. Challenge to Six Sigma in a high technology mass-manufacturing environments. Total Quality Management 15 (5/6), 699–706.

[67] Mullavey,F., 2005. Shack led by bad Six Sigma. Quality Digest, September /http://www.qualitydigest.com/sept05/articles/03_article. shtmlS.

[68] Neilson, G.L., Martin, K.L., Powers, E., 2008. The secrets to successful strategy execution. Harvard Business Review 86 (6), 60–70.

[69] Ostram, D., 2000. Corporate Japan’s restructuring efforts: a progress report. Japan Economic Institute Report, 20, May 19.

[70] Pande, P. S., Robert, P. N., & Roland, R. C. (2002). The Six Sigma way team field book. New York: McGraw-Hill.

[71] Pande, P.S., Neuman,R.P., Cavanagh,R., 2000. The Six Sigma Way: How GE, Motorola, and Other Top Companies are Honing their Performance. McGraw-Hill, NewYork, NY.

[72] Pullin, J., 2005. Room for improvement. Professional Engineering 18 (15), 38–138.

[73] Pyzdek, T.,2003. The Six Sigma Handbook: A Complete Guide for Green Belts, Black Belts, and Managers at All Levels. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.

[74] Rajagopalan,R.,Francis,M.,Suarez,W.,2004.Developing novel catalysts with Six Sigma. Research Technology Management 47,13–16.

[75] Reed, R., Lemak, D.J., Montgomery, J.C., 1996. Beyond process: TQM content and firm performance. Academy of Management Review 21, 173–202.

[76] Sakakibara, S., Flynn, F., Schroeder, R., Morris, W., 1997. The impact of just-in-time manufacturing and its infrastructure on manufacturing performance. Management Science 43 (9), 1246–1257.

[77] Savolainen,T., Haikonen,A., 2007. Dynamics of organizational learning and continuous improvement in Six Sigma implementation. The TQM Magazine 19(1), 6–17. [78] Schon, D.A., 1975. Deutero-learning in organizations: learning for increased effectiveness. Organizational Dynamics 4 (1), 2–16.

[79] Schonberger, R.J., 2008. Best Practices in Lean and Six Sigma Process Improvement. John Wiley & Sons, Hobokon, NJ.

[80] Schroeder,R.G., Linderman, K., Liedtke, C., Choo, A.S., 2008. Six Sigma: definition and underlying theory. Journal of Operations Management 26 (4),536–554.

[81] Scott C, Westbrook R. New strategic tools for supplychain management. International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics 1991;21(1):23–33.

[82] Sinha, K.K., Van de Ven, A.H., 2005. Designing work within and between organizations. Organization Science 16 (4), 389– 408.

[83] Slater, R., 2000. The GE Way Fieldbook: Jack Welch’s Battle for Corporate Revolution. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.

[84] Snee, R.D.,Hoerl,R.W.,2003.Leading Six Sigma. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.

[85] Sousa, R., Voss, C.A., 2002. Quality management re-visited: a reflective review and agenda for future research. Journal of Operations Management 20, 91–109.

[86] Stamatis, D.H., 2000. Who needs Six Sigma, anyway? Quality Digest May. Available at http://www.qualitydigest.com/may00/html/sixsigmacon. html.

[87] Sutton, C., 2006. Getting the most out of Six Sigma. Quality Management (March), 46–48.

[88] Szeto, A.Y. T., Tsang, A.H.C., 2005.Antecedent to successful implementation of Six Sigma. International Journal of Six Sigma and Competitive Advantage1(3),307–322.

[89] Tan KC, Kannan VR, HandGeld RB. Supply chain management: supplier performance and Grmperformance. International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management 1998;34(3):2–9.

[90] Teece, D.J., 2007. Explicating dynamic capabilities: the nature and micro foundations of (sustainable) enterprise performance. Strategic Management Journal 28 (11), 1319– 1350.

[91] Thirumalai, S., Sinha, K.K., 2005. Customer satisfaction with order fulfillment in retail supply chains: implications of product type in electronic B2C transactions. Journal of Operations Management 23 (3/4), 291–303.

[92] Treichler,D., Carmichael,R., Kusmanoff,A., Lewis,J., Berthiez,G., 2002. Design for Six Sigma: 15 lessons learned. Quality Progress 35, 33–42.

[93] Watson,G.,2006. Building on Six Sigma effectiveness. AS Q Six Sigma Forum Magazine 5(4), 14–15.

[94] White, R., Pearson, J., Wilson, J., 1999. JIT manufacturing: A survey of implementations in small and large US manufacturers. Management Science 45 (1), 1–15.

[95] Wruck, K.H., Jensen, M.C., 1998. The two key principles behind effective TQM program. European Financial Management 4 (3), 401–423.

[96] Wu, C.W., Chen, C.L., 2006. An integrated structural model toward successful continuous improvement activity. Technovation 26 (5/6), 697–707.

[97] Wurtzel,M., 2008. Reasons for Six Sigma deployment failures. BPM Institute. June /http://www.bpminstitute.org/articles/article/article/reas ons-for-six-sigma-deployment-failures.htmlS.

[98] Zimmerman, J.P., Weiss,J., 2005. Six Sigma’s seven deadly sins. Quality 44,62–66.

[99] Zollo, M., Winter, S.G., 2002. Deliberate learning and the evolution of dynamic capabilities. Organization Science 13 (3), 339–351.

[100] Zu, X., Fredendall, L.D.,Douglas,T.J., 2008. The evolving theory of quality management: the role of Six Sigma. Journal of Operations Management 26,630–650.

Untitled Page